I am reading Hal Fulton's "The Ruby Way" On page 57 he makes the statement: "Class instance variables cannot be referenced from within instance methods and, in general are not very useful" huh?.. This , in my feeble mind, contradicts everything else I have ever read, except that the example he gives is similar to the @y = 7 example below, and in that case, @y is not available to the accessor or any other method that I have played with. In the following code, the original assignment of @x = 7 and @y = 5 don't seem to do anything, even with the attr_accessor. I know that both are read by the compiler as I can assign @y = 5/0 and get a division by zero error. So, could someone please explain why the accessor for @y does not work here. If I hand write a reader and writer for @y, it works just fine. There are different scopes here, but I had the impression that the accessor would break down that barrier and make @y available throughout the class just as the initialize method is able to access the class variable @x and assign the passed in value. That value is then available to the @x accessor. I thought for a while that the @y accessor might work in the singleton class of Myclass, but it doesn't. class Myclass attr_accessor :y, :x @x = 7 @y = 5 def initialize(new_val= l) @x = new_val ? new_val : 0 end end mc = Myclass.new(3) puts mc.y #=> Nil puts mc.x #-> 3 I know I can make the @x and @y class variables available to instance methods by referencing them inside defined methods and the scope seem to be class wide, but it just seems like the first assignments above should work as written. Thanks in advance