On Nov 15, 2007 11:48 AM, Suraj Kurapati <snk / gna.org> wrote:
> Marc Heiler wrote:
> > (By the way, an accessor_read that can query variables with ? on the end
> > would be nice in std ruby too... I am not complaining at all, ruby is so
> > flexible, I already use this for my code and i love it, like @file.readable?
> > that queries a "special" reader accessor... i think it reads nicer than
> > @file.readable but this is just my opinion)
>
> Do you mean that attr_accessor treats symbols with a question mark
> differently by creating a "symbol_without_question=" writer method and a
> "symbol_with_question" reader method?  For example:
>
>   class Foo
>     attr_acessor :readable?  # defines Foo#readable= and Foo#readable?
>   end
>
>   f = Foo.new
>   f.readable? #=> nil
>   f.readable = 99
>   f.readable? #=> 99
>
> This would be very useful, because it would make the following
> workaround obsolete:
>
>   class Foo
>     attr_writer :readable  # only defines Foo#readable=
>
>     def readable?
>       @readable
>     end
>   end
>
> Oh wishing star, here is another wish for you! :-)
> Thanks for your consideration.

I would think that you would want to maintain the ? behavior across
the board.  In other words, it should return TrueClass or FalseClass
objects.

Todd